After Emily by Julie Dobrow
The Emily Dickinson legend is well known: a recluse and a genius, she left nearly 1800 poems, a trove discovered by her sister after the poet’s death in 1886. From that moment, many things could have happened. The poems could have been destroyed with many of Dickinson’s other papers. Or looked at and dismissed. That they were treated as something “full of power” is the result of luck, planning, adultery, and the tireless work of Mabel Loomis Todd and her daughter Millicent Todd Bingham. While scholars are still divided about the role these women played in editing the manuscripts and developing Dickinson’s popular image, Julie Dobrow’s detailed study of their lives and work, After Emily (W.W. Norton, $27.95), shows that they both made diligent efforts to present the poems accurately. A little like these first editors, struggling to decipher handwriting and make order from a chaos of papers, Dobrow went through seven hundred boxes of journals, diaries, letters, and other documents that Mabel and Millicent accumulated. As a result, this book is a vivid, realistic double portrait of two remarkable women.